Active Listening In Jazz, Ep. 8): Story & Motif

Hello everybody, my name is Dan Adler and I’d like to welcome you to Episode 8) of Active Listening in Jazz.

In this series we’ve been talking about elements of Jazz and how can you recognize them. And I want to give you a little bit of motivation now. When Jazz musicians are asked to explain what they are doing, very often they will give the analogy of storytelling. They are telling a story.

Story Smart by Kendall Haven

The first thing I’m going to reference is a book that I’ve been reading lately. It’s called Story Smart by Kendall Haven.

And Kendall Haven has analysed thousands of stories and has analysed audience responses to stories.

Kendall Haven: Our brain needs to make sense of stories that we hear

And he has analysed a set of elements which are more likely to keep your attention during a storytelling session and to memorable to you.

One of those elements ~ the first and most important element is that our brain needs to make sense of stories that we hear.

Let’s list to Kendall Haven explain that important point.

What we’re able to show, to take from other people’s work actually, developmental psychologists work is this concept of the make sense mandate.

Kendall Haven: Make Sense Mandate

Either you make sense of information as it comes to you or you ignore it.”

If you are listening to Jazz and you can’t make sense out of it at all, then you are going to ignore it.

What is a motif?

So now we are going to talk about one of the most important building blocks about Jazz and that is the idea of a musical motif.

And one of the definitions of a musical motif is more generic.  Doesn’t apply just to Jazz, Doesn’t just apply to music.

It’s a general idea that you have … An image, an idea.

It could be a musical idea or a linguistic idea or a word. Or something that is repeated several times in a particular work or text.

In our case we’re talking about a Jazz solo. And it is a unifying device that helps you put things together and helps you connect to the different parts that you are listening to. And it may have symbolic or thematic significance.

Meaning it may actually be something that is being developed or is a significant part of the story that is being told to you.

Martin Luther King

So let me start with one non-musical example and we’ll look at one of the most famous speeches in history: Martin Luther King‘s ‘I have a dream‘ speech.

And let’s look at how he used recurring techniques to give structure to different sections of the speech and make it flow.

 

Martin Luther King: ‘I have a dream’ speech transcript

 

So he starts with ‘Five score years ago‘ and continues to talk about ‘a hundred years later‘ … ‘a hundred years later‘ … ‘a hundred years later

~ and then:

‘Now is the time’ …  ‘Now is the time’ … …  ‘Now is the time‘…

~ and then another motif around:

… ‘we must‘ … ‘we must‘ … ‘we must

~ and then:

Martin Luther King: ‘I have a dream’ speech transcript


we can never be satisfied‘ … ‘we can never be satisfied‘ …

we have to go back to‘ … ‘go back

and of course ..

I have a dream‘ … ‘I have a dream‘ … ‘I have a dream‘ …

and then it finally ends with:

Let freedom ring‘ … ‘Let freedom ring‘ … ‘Let freedom ring‘ …

So a musical motif can be as simple as one note and we’ll look at one example which is a very famous song by Antônio Carlos Jobim which is ‘One Note Samba’.

Frank Sinatra with Antônio Carlos Jobim:  One Note Samba

In the first part of this song he takes one single note and just puts it with a rhythmic

Do Ba Di Bee Dwee Do Dahh

idea.  ‘ta, ta,  ta, ta, ta, ta, ta, ta, ta, ta

This is just a little samba built upon a single note. Other notes are bound to follow, but the root is still that note.

Now this new one is the consequence of the one we’ve just been through.

As I’m bound to  be the unavoidable consequence of you.”

 

 

And this same idea carries over to Jazz soloing.  Sometimes Jazz musicians will take a little germ of a musical idea ~ a motif.  And keep developing it. Morphing it. Repeating it.

 

 

So let’s look at a musical motif that has become so famous it has its own Wikipedia page and its own Facebook page.


It’s called The Lick and goes:

Doo Ba Di Bee Dwee Do Dahh

Here’s another very famous phrase. This one comes  from the theme of Charlie Parker‘s Cool Blues.

Charlie Parker: ‘Cool Blues’ & ‘Yardbird Suite’
Conrad Herwig: Georgia On My Mind and Eric Reed: ‘Blooz First Thing This Morning’
Daniel Smith: ‘Yardbird Tune’ and Charlie Parker: Cheryl’
Howard McGhee: ‘Now’s The Time’ and Charlie Parker: ’52nd Street Theme;’
Fats Navarro: ‘Ornithology’ and Dwayne Clemons: : ‘Live in Piteå’
Charlie Parker: ‘Leo The Lion’ and Herbie Williams: ‘Now’s The Time’
J.J Johnson: ‘Eronel’
Sonny Rollins

Not all motifs are repetitions of well known licks or phrases. Sometimes it could just be an idea and developing

Sonny Rollins: Saxophone Colossus

that idea.

So let’s listen to the way Sonny Rollins opens the solo on one of his great tunes ‘St Thomas‘. And on this tune he starts with a two note idea.

 

 

He goes ‘ta dah   … ta dah‘  … then he changes it a little bit … ‘ta dah‘.

Then he moves it a little bit rhythmically and then he repeats it twice … ‘ta dah   … ta dah‘.

And then you can see how he develops that and keeps that going for about two choruses until he had enough of this idea and starts to develop new ideas.

Sonny Rollins: ‘St Thomas’, score
Sonny Rollins: ‘St Thomas’ 2nd Chorus

 

Even without following the musical notation on that I’m sure you’re able to hear that motif and the way it was developed by Sonny Rollins.

Wes Montgomery

And now let’s listen to another one of my favorite players, Wes Montgomery who was also great at being able to take a motif and keep it going for a long period of time. And develop it in a very exciting way.

This is a Blues called ‘No Blues’ from his very famous album called ‘Smoking at The Half Note.

And check out this one chorus in which he plays one phrase for the whole Blues chorus.

Wes Montgomery: ‘No Blues’

And I hope you can refer back to the episode where we discussed Blues form and hear the Blues form by the rhythm section while Wes is playing this one phrase, over and over again.

In the next two Blues choruses you get to hear Wes using a new motif where he is emphasizing the second beat of every bar.

 

Wes Montgomery and Wynton Kelly: ‘Smokin’ At The Half Note’

 

So if you count 1, 2, 3, 4  … 1, 2, 3, 4 … as we talked about in the previous episode about the rhythm section.

And he starts emphasizing the second beat using an octave that he keeps repeating and in between that second beat, of every other bar he keeps repeating phrases.

And at some point you can see the  rhythm section catches on and starts to emphasize those beats together with him, until at some point he decides ‘ok, I’ve had enough of this idea. I’ve got a new idea.’ And he move right along to a new motif.

‘The Surrey With a Fringe On Top’, by Rogers and Hammerstein

And another very popular source of Jazz motifs comes from the great American songbook. For example ‘The Surrey With a Fringe on Top‘ from the musical Oklahoma by Rodgers and Hammerstein.

 

So this next example is from my album ‘Back To The Bridge’ with the great Joey DeFrancesco.

 

And at some point I got it into my mind to play this phrase from ‘Surrey With A Fringe on Top’ and you can see that I play it for a very short period of time and then I kind of moved on.

But then something amazing happened when my solo ends Joey DeFrancesco the great organist, first of all he starts his solo by taking my last phrase and taking that as the first phrase of his solo.

But then right after that he goes back to that quote and he uses that to develop his next idea.

So I hope you’re beginning to see how a motif  can be used either by a single player, sometimes passing from one player to the next.

Sometimes connecting with the rhythm section. Sometimes taking a motif from the rhythm and developing it melodically.

Sometimes taking a melodic idea and developing it rhythmically. And all of these things are things that the Active Listener is trying to stay on top of.

Jeremiah Macdonald’s ‘Jazz Dispute’ featuring Charlie Parker’s and Dizzy Gillespie’s recording of “Leap Frog”

But sometimes the Jazz phrasing can get very fast and you might think at that point you can’t exactly stay on top of it.  You can’t exactly determine what’s going on.

But here’s a great example from Jeremiah Macdonald. He took one of the fastest tunes by Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie where they’re playing solos and exchanging phrases and he stages it as a ‘Jazz Dispute‘ as he calls it.

And the beautiful part of that is that it kind of gives you a framework to think that maybe there is conversation going on.

Even if I can’t exactly follow the exact musical notes and the exact pitches going on.  Or why they are happening harmonically. I can kind of see how the phrasing works and how you can interpret it as a dispute or interpret it as a conversation.

You can interpret it in many different ways as long as it makes sense to your mind. As I mentioned in the beginning of the episode we have this internal mandate to makes sense of what we hear.

And so as you begin to become a more Active Listener you will start making more connections between what is happening on the bandstand or in the album and you will connect it with show tunes.

Or you will connect it with Jazz solos.  Or you will connect with what you just heard from another player.

And all of these things connect contribute to your enjoyment of this beautiful art form. So thank you very much for joining me for Episode 8) of Active Listening in Jazz and I will see you in Episode 9).

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

Check out my Active Listening in Jazz for Non-Musicians Facebook Group. Join today to find out more.

See my Active Listening in Jazz for Non-Musicians Youtube Playlist.

 

Subscribe to the playlist to learn about new episodes.

Episode 1) Intro & Singlalong  Dan Adler blog series
Episode 2) The Blues
Episode 3) Form
Episode 4) Miles Davis, ‘So What?’
Episode 5) Harmony & Improv
Episode 6) Jazz Expression
Episode 7) Rhythm Section
Episode 8) Story and Motif

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.